My DA was refused
After a council refuses a development application in New South Wales, there is usually a right to seek merits review of the decision in the Land and Environment Court, and often opportunities to negotiate, amend or strengthen the proposal before or during that process.
- New South Wales
- Issue overview
- Time-sensitive
On this page
This page may be relevant if:
- You have received a notice of determination refusing your DA
- Your DA was approved but with conditions you cannot accept
- You are weighing whether to appeal, amend and resubmit, or negotiate
- You are unsure how long you have to act
What this usually means
- A refusal sets out the reasons the consent authority was not satisfied; those reasons then frame any appeal or amended proposal.
- Most DA refusals can be challenged by way of a merits appeal (commonly a Class 1 appeal) in the Land and Environment Court, where the Court re-decides the application.
- Appeal rights are time-limited. For an applicant appeal against an actual determination, the period is six months after the determination is notified or registered on the NSW Planning Portal. Since 21 March 2026 an appeal cannot be lodged while a review of the determination under Division 8.2 is under way, and the time the review takes does not count towards the six months. Confirming the exact dates early still matters, because the right lapses if the period runs out.
- Amended plans, further information and expert evidence can often address the reasons for refusal.
What commonly matters
-
The reasons for refusal
Each ground of refusal needs to be tested. Some are answerable with evidence or amendments; others go to fundamental planning merit.
-
Time limits
Appeal periods are strict. Identifying the deadline early preserves your options and avoids a procedural dead end.
-
Evidence and experts
Planning, urban design, heritage, traffic, acoustic or environmental evidence is often decisive. The right experts depend on the grounds of refusal.
-
Negotiation and amendment
Conciliation and amended plans frequently resolve appeals without a contested hearing, but the strategy needs to be set early.
How we help
- Review the refusal and assess the prospects of a successful appeal
- Identify time limits and the correct review pathway
- Advise on amended plans, further information and the expert evidence required
- Represent you in conciliation, negotiation and Land and Environment Court proceedings
This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.
Frequently asked questions
General information only, not legal advice. The position depends on your circumstances.
Can I ask the council to review its decision instead of appealing to the Court?
A Division 8.2 review under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) may be available, depending on the decision-maker, development category, earlier reviews and the applicable deadline. Designated development, Crown development and complying development certificates are excluded. A deemed refusal cannot be reviewed under that Division, and a determination or decision already reviewed cannot be reviewed again. The review must generally be requested within the applicable appeal period; a rejection decision has a separate 14-day review-request period. The relevant review period is disregarded when calculating the appeal period, and section 8.9A restricts commencing an appeal while the review is underway. Withdrawal ends that restriction but does not give a new full appeal period. Panel determinations are generally reviewed by the relevant panel, while an applicant whose application was determined by council staff can request review by the council's local planning panel, if it has one. As at 14 October 2026, the enacted amendments removing Sydney district and regional planning panels from these review provisions had not commenced. Eligibility, transitional rules and dates should be checked before choosing between review and appeal.
What is a section 34 conciliation conference in the Land and Environment Court?
A section 34 conciliation conference is a structured, without-prejudice meeting under the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW) in which the parties, with a Commissioner, try to reach agreement on a Class 1 appeal, often after amended plans or further information have been provided. If the parties agree on a decision the Court could lawfully make, the Commissioner must dispose of the proceedings in accordance with it. Agreement does not dispense with legal preconditions to consent. If no agreement is reached, the matter generally proceeds to a hearing. Many DA refusal appeals are resolved at this stage, but whether agreement is possible depends on the grounds of refusal and the evidence.
How much does it cost to appeal a refused DA in NSW?
The cost of a Class 1 merits appeal in the Land and Environment Court varies widely and usually includes a Court filing fee, your lawyers' fees and the cost of expert evidence such as planning, urban design, heritage or traffic reports. The scale and number of experts, whether the appeal settles at a section 34 conciliation conference or runs to a contested hearing, and the complexity of the grounds of refusal all affect the overall cost. In Class 1 proceedings each party generally bears its own costs, but the Court can order costs where that is fair and reasonable. Separately, leave to amend a development application in proceedings generally requires an order for the applicant to pay the consent authority's costs thrown away, unless the amendment is minor; the rule excludes proceedings under section 34AA. These rules should not be assumed to apply identically to a modification application. The likely expense, delay, stress and risk of an unsuccessful appeal should be weighed against the potential benefit before proceedings are started.
Is it better to lodge a new DA or appeal the refusal?
Both options can be available after a refusal, and which is more appropriate depends on the grounds of refusal, the scope of changes needed and the relevant time limits. Lodging a fresh or amended development application may suit cases where the proposal can be substantially redesigned, while a Land and Environment Court appeal (often involving amended plans and conciliation) may suit cases where the planning merit is sound but the council was not satisfied. The applicant appeal period is six months after the determination is notified or registered on the NSW Planning Portal. Since 21 March 2026 an appeal cannot be lodged while a Division 8.2 review is under way, and the time the review takes does not count towards the six months, so a review can be sought without giving up the appeal option; the practical effect of each pathway on timing still depends on the facts and should be confirmed early.
Related situations
- Planning & development Council has not determined my application Assess your options where council has not determined your application within the expected assessment period.
- Planning & development I need to modify a consent or challenge conditions Modification applications, unworkable conditions, the substantially the same development test and your review and appeal options.
- Council & regulatory I received an order from council Respond to notices of intention, orders (including stop work orders), compliance action and enforcement risk.
- Planning & development I need planning due diligence Identify planning controls, approval pathways, constraints, environmental risks and feasibility before committing.
Where to start
Talk to us about your DA refusal
Tell us about the refusal, when you received the decision and your goals for the site. On a short preliminary call we can tell you whether we can assist and what the first step would be.
30 minutes · Phone or Teams · No charge
The complimentary 30-minute preliminary call is intended to discuss whether we can assist and what an initial scope of work would involve. It is not intended to provide legal advice. Ask us to confirm in writing the work we have agreed to undertake. Tell us any date stated in the documents. Do not assume that sending an enquiry or making a booking protects a deadline. Ask us to confirm the work we have agreed to undertake, including any action about a deadline. If a date is close or uncertain, seek prompt legal advice rather than waiting for an online reply.