I want a government decision reconsidered
A decision can affect a licence, project or business without providing an obvious route to challenge it. We examine the decision and governing legislation before advising whether reconsideration, merits review, an appeal or judicial review could assist.
- New South Wales
- Issue overview
- Time-sensitive
On this page
This page may be relevant if:
- You have received a refusal, restriction or other adverse decision
- You need to know whether internal or external review is available
- You are comparing a challenge with negotiation or a revised application
What this usually means
- Review rights depend on the decision and the statutory scheme. Not every decision carries a right to merits review.
- Merits review examines the decision under the powers given to the review body. Judicial review concerns legal validity; it is not a general opportunity to obtain a preferred result.
- Identify the correct applicant, forum, preliminary steps and time limit. Do not assume a complaint, correspondence or an information request preserves a review right.
What commonly matters
-
The decision and the objective
Obtain the decision, reasons and notification record. Identify whether the practical aim is a different condition, a fresh decision or another form of relief.
-
The available pathway
Check jurisdiction and any required internal review. A process available for one kind of licence or approval may not apply to another.
-
Value and risk
Compare the likely benefit with legal fees, expert evidence, delay and potential exposure to another party's costs. A successful procedural challenge may still lead to the same substantive result.
How we help
- Identify available review and appeal pathways
- Assess evidence, remedies and the value of proceedings
- Prepare review applications and conduct proceedings within our practice areas
This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.
Related situations
- Council & regulatory I question the legality of a government decision NSW judicial review of government decisions affecting land and business: statutory power, process, remedies, evidence and the limits of a successful challenge.
- Council & regulatory A decision may take effect before my challenge is heard NSW stays and interim orders in land and regulatory disputes: immediate consequences, evidence, the underlying proceedings and costs risks.
- Council & regulatory I need the reasons or records behind a decision NSW government information and reasons requests: identifying useful records, GIPA access pathways, statutory limits and related review deadlines.
- Council & regulatory An authority is proposing an adverse decision against me Preparing NSW show-cause responses and representations about proposed government decisions, including evidence, statutory criteria and workable alternatives.
Where to start
Discuss government decision review
Start with the decision and its practical consequences. A preliminary call can establish whether we can help assess the review options and urgent dates.
30 minutes · Phone or Teams · No charge
The complimentary 30-minute preliminary call is intended to discuss whether we can assist and what an initial scope of work would involve. It is not intended to provide legal advice. Ask us to confirm in writing the work we have agreed to undertake. Tell us any date stated in the documents. Do not assume that sending an enquiry or making a booking protects a deadline. Ask us to confirm the work we have agreed to undertake, including any action about a deadline. If a date is close or uncertain, seek prompt legal advice rather than waiting for an online reply.