Compulsory acquisition in NSW: negotiations and valuation
- 14 October 2026
- Michael Themis, Principal Solicitor
- New South Wales
How to approach the six-month negotiation period, acquisition-date valuation, project effects and the terms of an agreement for compulsory acquisition in NSW.
On this page
- When the six-month negotiation period begins
- Identify what is being acquired and who holds the interests
- Understand the valuation date before discussing price
- Separate market changes from the effects of the project
- Make an informed decision before putting plans on hold
- Negotiate compensation, possession and payment terms
When a government authority proposes to acquire a property, the first formal stage will usually be a six-month period of negotiation. That period gives the owner an opportunity to establish what should be paid, negotiate when and how to leave, and resolve what happens to any land or business that is retained. This article concerns acquisitions by NSW authorities under the Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 (NSW) (Just Terms Act).
Agreeing a price, postponing development, ending a tenancy or committing to replacement premises can have consequences that a later compensation claim will not necessarily repair.
An owner who already has a compensation notice should check the Court objection deadline immediately. Under section 66(1), a person who has claimed compensation under Part 3 may, within 90 days after receiving a compensation notice, lodge with the Land and Environment Court an objection to the amount of compensation offered by the authority. Continuing negotiations does not stop that period. The amended-notice rules can affect the date from which it runs. Just Terms Act, ss 43A and 66. The amended-notice rules and late-objection provisions are explained in the article on proposed acquisition and compensation notices.
When the six-month negotiation period begins
Under section 10A(2), the authority “is to make a genuine attempt to acquire the land by agreement for at least 6 months before giving a proposed acquisition notice” (PAN). The parties can reach agreement earlier, agree to a longer period, or continue negotiating after a PAN. The six months is a minimum negotiation period, not a deadline by which the owner must accept an offer. Just Terms Act, s 10A.
The authority will usually send a commencement or opening letter. NSW Government standards identify receipt of that letter, “or such other date as is appropriate in the circumstances”, as the starting point, with genuine negotiations to follow. Record when it arrives and confirm the proposed timetable. A public announcement about a project does not, by itself, establish that six months of genuine negotiations with the owner has begun. NSW Government minimum negotiation requirements.
The period can be shortened by agreement. The Minister responsible for the authority may approve a shorter period, but only if satisfied that “the urgency of the matter or other circumstances of the case make it impracticable to have any longer period of negotiation”. That approval requires the concurrence of the Minister administering the Act. Section 10A excludes Crown land and the underground acquisitions specified in subsection (1). The authority need not comply if the owner notifies it that the owner is not prepared to negotiate for acquisition by agreement, or if the owner cannot be located after reasonable inquiries.
When responding to an inadequate offer, explain why it is unacceptable and what information or terms would allow negotiations to progress. Rejecting a particular price need not amount to notifying the authority that the owner is not prepared to negotiate. Just Terms Act, s 10A(6).
Identify what is being acquired and who holds the interests
Obtain the acquisition plan and proposed terms at the outset. Establish whether the authority wants the whole property, part of it, an easement or a temporary interest. For an easement, the rights to enter, construct, maintain and restrict the owner’s use may matter as much as the area shown on the plan.
Identify the registered owner, tenants, business operator and mortgagee, including any separate companies involved. Section 37 gives an entitlement to compensation to an owner of an interest in land “which is divested, extinguished or diminished by an acquisition notice”. Their interests and losses must be assessed separately. A claim by the property owner does not automatically recover a tenant’s or associated company’s loss. In The Owners – Strata Plan 67754, the owners corporation’s acquired interest could not be valued by reference to lost rental income from shops it did not own. Just Terms Act, s 37; The Owners – Strata Plan 67754 v Sydney Metro [2026] NSWLEC 99, [53]–[54].
When assessing market value for compensation payable to several former owners, section 56(2) provides that the sum of the market values of each interest “must not (except with the approval of the Minister responsible for the authority of the State) exceed the market value of the land at the date of acquisition”. This is a limit on the aggregate market values, not a cap on all compensation. Just Terms Act, s 56(2).
If the proposed acquisition is below ground, check section 62 before assuming land-value compensation is available. Where the acquisition consists only of an underground easement or right to use land for construction and maintenance of works, compensation is limited to “actual damage done in the construction of the work or caused by the work”. For subsurface land compulsorily acquired to construct a tunnel, compensation is not payable, subject to section 62(1), unless one of the conditions in section 62(2), concerning the surface, its support, or mines or underground workings, is satisfied. Just Terms Act, s 62.
If a smaller acquisition, different access arrangement or revised construction footprint would materially improve the owner’s position, raise it while those matters remain open. Obtain advice before the acquisition notice is published in the NSW Government Gazette if there is a basis to question the authority’s acquisition power or process. Section 10A(7) provides: “Nothing in this section gives rise to, or can be taken into account in, any civil cause of action.” Once acquisition has occurred, section 33 prevents the specified failures concerning notice of proposed acquisition under Part 2, or subsequent failures to comply with the Act relating to the acquisition, from affecting its validity. The Act does not itself confer a power to acquire land where the authority otherwise lacks that power. A dispute about compensation does not itself prevent an otherwise lawful acquisition. Just Terms Act, ss 7, 10A(7) and 33.
Understand the valuation date before discussing price
For compulsory acquisition under the Act, market value is assessed at the date of acquisition: the date the acquisition notice is published in the NSW Government Gazette. The project announcement, opening letter, PAN and compensation notice each serve a different purpose; none fixes that statutory valuation date. Just Terms Act, ss 20, 55–56.
Section 56(1) defines market value by reference to “the amount that would have been paid for the land if it had been sold at that time by a willing but not anxious seller to a willing but not anxious buyer”, subject to the statutory disregards. Relevant evidence includes comparable sales, lawful uses, planning controls, physical constraints and development potential. In Barkat, the Court restated the valuation principle: “The land must be valued at the relevant date in its existing condition with all its potentialities as potentialities.” A realistic prospect of a more valuable use can therefore contribute to value, assessed with its costs, timing and risks rather than as an already completed development. Barkat v Roads and Maritime Services [2019] NSWCA 240, [20]–[21].
An early valuation provides a basis for negotiations. If acquisition occurs later, market movements and relevant changes in the property’s circumstances must be considered at that later date. There is no general rule freezing compensation at the first offer or project announcement. Conversely, section 63 permits an authority and an owner to agree on the amount of compensation, or a matter affecting that amount, if the land is acquired by compulsory process “within a time (or in the circumstances) specified in the agreement”. Such an agreement “has effect according to its tenor”. Check the effect of its terms before signing. Just Terms Act, s 63.
Instruct a valuer experienced in compulsory acquisition early, with legal advice on the interest and assumptions to be valued. Have the reports exchanged and the differences explained: are the valuers disagreeing about sales evidence, development potential, project effects or the legal basis of the claim? A supported counteroffer should identify those disagreements and explain the changes sought.
Separate market changes from the effects of the project
Section 56(1)(a) requires “any increase or decrease in the value of the land caused by the carrying out of, or the proposal to carry out, the public purpose for which the land was acquired” to be disregarded. The exercise remains a valuation at the acquisition date. It does not simply substitute the property’s price before the project was announced. Just Terms Act, s 56(1)(a).
Section 56(1)(a) requires identification of the public purpose for which the land was acquired and the change in value that purpose caused. A broad description such as “the infrastructure project” may conceal several legally distinct projects and decisions.
In Goldmate, the Court of Appeal rejected an approach that treated the M12 acquisition as serving the broader development of Western Sydney Airport. On the subsequent valuation in 2026, the Land and Environment Court retained the value associated with airport-related rezoning because it was not caused by the M12 public purpose. Goldmate [2024] NSWCA 292, [71]–[79]; Goldmate [2026] NSWLEC 22, [56]–[66].
In Roberts Jones, decided on 21 August 2026, the Court rejected a claimed connection between the M12 acquisition and the effect of a separate transport corridor on retained land. The required causal connection was not established; the owner also failed to prove that the corridor would have been elsewhere without the M12. Roberts Jones Badgerys Creek Pty Ltd v Transport for NSW [2026] NSWLEC 108, [77]–[97].
Preserve the planning and project history from the first approach: earlier controls, approvals, project maps, announcements and correspondence about restrictions or changed plans. Use those records to show what changed, why it changed and how it affected value. The fact that a change followed the announcement does not, by itself, establish that the public purpose caused it.
Make an informed decision before putting plans on hold
An acquisition announcement can make it commercially sensible to pause development. It does not follow that compensation will value the property as though the paused work had been completed.
In Sydney Metro v G & J Drivas Pty Ltd [2024] NSWCA 5, the owners slowed and then stopped redevelopment after learning of the proposed acquisition. The Court rejected a valuation that assumed unperformed development steps had occurred. It explained that “increases or decreases in value caused only by choices made by the owner because of the proposed acquisition are not to be disregarded pursuant to s 56(1)(a)”. The Court also recognised that a rezoning or development consent may require a different causal analysis where an application would likely have been refused because of the public purpose. Drivas, [35]–[43], [88]–[89].
Before suspending an application, allowing an approval to lapse, ending a lease or abandoning works, assess the cost of continuing, the realistic acquisition timetable and the effect of stopping on value. Record the reasons and any direction or request from the authority. If the authority wants work deferred, seek written terms addressing the consequences. A record helps prove what happened; it does not itself create an entitlement to compensation.
Take advice before advertising or listing the property for sale during negotiations. Section 5(2) provides: “This Act does not apply to any such acquisition if the land is available for public sale and the land is acquired by agreement.” Section 5(3) includes advertising, listing with a real estate agent and otherwise holding the land out as available for sale. Obtaining valuation advice is a different step. Just Terms Act, s 5(2)–(3).
Negotiate compensation, possession and payment terms
For a proposed acquisition by agreement of land not available for public sale, section 38 requires the authority to take into account the same matters as Part 3 requires for compulsory acquisition. Just Terms Act, s 38.
Section 55 requires regard to be had to the following matters only, as assessed in accordance with Division 4:
(a) the market value of the land on the date of its acquisition,
(b) any special value of the land to the person on the date of its acquisition,
(c) any loss attributable to severance,
(d) any loss attributable to disturbance,
(e) the disadvantage resulting from relocation,
(f) any increase or decrease in the value of any other land of the person at the date of acquisition which adjoins or is severed from the acquired land by reason of the carrying out of, or the proposal to carry out, the public purpose for which the land was acquired.
Each has its own requirements. These amounts cannot simply be added together where that would compensate the same loss twice. Under section 55(f), a qualifying increase in the value of retained land can reduce compensation. Disadvantage resulting from relocation concerns the non-financial disadvantage of relocating a principal residence and is subject to a statutory maximum with indexation. Just Terms Act, ss 55–61 and Schedule 1A.
A valuation based on potential for a different use also affects what other compensation can be claimed. Section 61 provides:
If the market value of land is assessed on the basis that the land had potential to be used for a purpose other than that for which it is currently used, compensation is not payable in respect of—
(a) any financial advantage that would necessarily have been forgone in realising that potential, and
(b) any financial loss that would necessarily have been incurred in realising that potential.
The exclusion concerns those necessary consequences of realising the potential; it does not exclude every disturbance claim associated with the existing use. Just Terms Act, s 61.
Prepare the supporting material during negotiations. For a partial acquisition, document access, servicing and the practical use of the remaining land. For relocation, obtain realistic premises options, quotations and timing information. Keep invoices and explain the connection between each claimed expense and the acquisition.
For compulsory acquisition, section 59(1)(a) includes “legal costs reasonably incurred by the persons entitled to compensation in connection with the compulsory acquisition of the land”. Section 59(1)(b) includes “valuation fees of a qualified valuer reasonably incurred by those persons in connection with the compulsory acquisition of the land (but not fees calculated by reference to the value, as assessed by the valuer, of the land)”. Just Terms Act, s 59(1)(a)–(b).
NSW Government minimum requirements state that reasonably incurred legal and valuation fees will be covered as part of the agreed compensation package; section 38 requires the authority to take into account the section 59(1)(b) exclusion of fees calculated by reference to the value, as assessed by the valuer, of the land. Confirm the scope of work, reimbursement arrangements and payment timing in writing early, including what happens if acquisition does not proceed. Section 69’s compensation entitlement for withdrawal depends on a PAN having been given; it does not apply merely because negotiations cease before that stage. NSW Government minimum negotiation requirements; Just Terms Act, s 69.
The article on costs in compulsory acquisition explains how these costs differ from the costs of Court proceedings, and which records support them.
Section 59(1)(f) also includes:
any other financial costs reasonably incurred (or that might reasonably be incurred), relating to the actual use of the land, as a direct and natural consequence of the acquisition.
The article on disturbance loss explains each of the six categories in section 59 and the evidence that supports them.
Negotiate possession, relocation time, access, any accommodation works and payment arrangements alongside price. Before accepting a package, identify what the release settles, which costs remain to be assessed and what happens if acquisition is delayed or its scope changes.
Where the authority and owners agree in writing to compulsory acquisition, section 30(2) disapplies Division 1 of Part 2 and Part 3 if the owners “have agreed in writing on all relevant matters concerning the compulsory acquisition and the compensation to be paid for the acquisition”. An agreement satisfying that provision removes the usual Part 3 compensation and objection procedure. Obtain advice on whether the proposed agreement has that effect before signing. Just Terms Act, s 30(2).
For the next stages, read Compulsory acquisition in NSW: the PAN and compensation notice. For choosing a lawyer to run the claim, read Choosing a lawyer for a compulsory acquisition claim in NSW.
This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.
Principal Solicitor · Stone & Pillar Legal
Michael brings experience of both private practice and government to planning, environmental regulation and compulsory acquisition. Trained at Herbert Smith Freehills and King & Wood Mallesons, he has senior in-house experience across the Commonwealth and New South Wales governments.
(02) 8014 5817 michael@stonepillar.com.au Level 13, 111 Elizabeth StreetSydney NSW 2000
Legislation on this page
- Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 (NSW) ss 5, 7, 10A, 20, 30, 37, 38, 55, 56, 59, 61, 62, 63, 66, 69 Official text read 29 September 2026; version in force from 5 July 2024.
Related insights
This article sits within our Compulsory acquisition and compensation practice.