Skip to content

Compulsory acquisition

Choosing a lawyer for a compulsory acquisition claim in NSW

Published
21 November 2026
By
Michael Themis, Principal Solicitor
Jurisdiction
New South Wales

How a NSW landowner chooses a compulsory acquisition lawyer: the work at each stage, who the lawyer acts for, who runs the claim, costs and the Court.

Aerial view of a construction site cut through a town centre beside a main road
On this page

For a NSW landowner, the right compulsory acquisition lawyer acts for the owner, has no conflict with the acquiring authority, and can say who will run the claim under the Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 (NSW) (Just Terms Act), from the first negotiation to the Land and Environment Court if proceedings are needed. The lawyer instructs valuers and other experts on the assumptions the Act requires, and discloses in writing what the work will cost and which costs may be claimed as compensation and which may not. This article sets out how to test a lawyer against each of those points before signing a costs agreement.

In this article “owner” includes a tenant or a business with an interest in the land that the acquisition affects; each may hold a claim of its own. The article is general information about choosing a lawyer in New South Wales, not advice on a particular acquisition.

What is a compulsory acquisition lawyer engaged to do?

The lawyer’s job changes with the stage of the acquisition, and the owner should expect a clear account of the work at each stage. In the negotiation period before any notice, the work is to establish what the authority proposes, what the land and any business are worth under the heads of compensation the Act names (explained below), and what the owner should and should not agree to. After a proposed acquisition notice, it is to lodge the claim for compensation with the evidence that supports it. After the compensation notice, it is to test the Valuer-General’s determination and, if the owner objects to the amount, to run the claim in the Land and Environment Court.

Stage What the acquiring authority does What the owner’s lawyer does
Negotiation Must make a genuine attempt to acquire the land by agreement for at least six months before giving a proposed acquisition notice, unless the owner agrees to a shorter period or the responsible Minister approves one, with exceptions for Crown land, certain easements and tunnel strata, and where the owner is not prepared to negotiate or cannot be located (Just Terms Act, s 10A). Obtains the authority’s proposal in writing, commissions a valuation, advises on any access, acquisition or release document before it is signed, and records what is agreed.
Proposed acquisition notice Gives at least 90 days’ notice before the land is compulsorily acquired, unless the owner agrees in writing to a shorter period or the responsible Minister approves one (Just Terms Act, s 13). Lodges the claim for compensation with the authority or the Valuer-General in the prescribed form, with the valuation and the evidence on each head (Just Terms Act, s 39).
Acquisition and compensation notice Within 45 days after the acquisition notice is published (a period the Minister may extend by up to 60 days to allow a valuation to be made), gives the former owner a compensation notice stating the amount offered as determined by the Valuer-General (Just Terms Act, s 42). Reads the determination and any valuation report against the claim, advises on acceptance, and prepares any objection.
Objection and Court Unless the parties agree or the Court decides otherwise, pays an advance of 90 per cent of the amount offered in the compensation notice within 28 days after being notified that proceedings have begun, or pays it into trust if the owner does not accept it (Just Terms Act, s 68). Files the Class 3 application, settles the contentions, briefs the valuer and counsel, attends the conciliation conference, and runs the hearing if there is one.

A claim for compensation because of a compulsory acquisition under the Just Terms Act is heard in Class 3 of the Court’s jurisdiction (Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW), ss 19, 24). The lawyer chosen should be able to say, for each stage, who will do the work and what it will cost.

When should an owner engage a lawyer?

Before anything is signed, and before the authority’s first offer is answered. The negotiation period under section 10A is when the owner’s evidence is assembled and the authority’s proposal is tested. An owner who waits until the proposed acquisition notice arrives has less time to assemble evidence. After the notice, the claim for compensation must be lodged, and the notice itself states the period for lodging it, which is not less than 60 days after the notice is given (Just Terms Act, s 15).

After a compensation notice, the periods are fixed by the Act. A person who has claimed compensation may, within 90 days after receiving the compensation notice, lodge with the Land and Environment Court an objection to the amount offered (Just Terms Act, s 66). A person who neither accepts the offer nor objects within that period is taken to have accepted it (Just Terms Act, s 45); a person taken to have accepted may still lodge an objection, but the Court hears it only if satisfied that there is good cause (Just Terms Act, s 66(3)). The period is strict. Objecting is not the only sound course: the offer may be fair. Proceedings take months, add expert, counsel and filing costs, and carry the risk of a lower determination and of an order for costs, so whether to object is a decision to take on the valuation evidence and advice. An owner who first consults a lawyer in the last days of the period may have little time to obtain a valuation.

An owner whose land has been designated for acquisition, and who would suffer hardship from waiting, may be able to require the authority to acquire it (Just Terms Act, s 23); the article on hardship acquisitions explains the rules that apply to compensation in that case.

Dates in an acquisition run from events that the owner may not be able to pin down without help: when a notice was received, when an acquisition notice was published in the Gazette, whether an amended notice restarted a period. A lawyer engaged early establishes them from the documents; the article on the proposed acquisition notice and the compensation notice explains what each does.

Who does the lawyer act for: owners, or acquiring authorities?

Some firms act mainly for owners, some mainly for authorities, and some for both. None of those is wrong, but the owner should know which it is before instructing. An owner should ask whether a firm that acts for Transport for NSW, Sydney Metro, Sydney Water or a council in other matters may for that reason be unable to act against it in this one.

Experience on an authority’s side gives familiarity with the statutory process as authorities apply it. It does not permit the use of that authority’s confidential information, and a lawyer who holds such information that is material to a matter may be unable to act against that authority in it. The question to ask is direct: how much of the firm’s acquisition work is for owners and how much for authorities, and is there any conflict with the authority in this matter? A firm should check conflicts, and confirm in writing whether it can act, before substantive work begins.

Who will run the matter and appear in the Land and Environment Court?

The person who meets the owner at the first conference is not always the person who runs the matter. In a larger practice the file may pass to a solicitor the owner has not met, with a partner reviewing at milestones. In a smaller practice the principal often does the work. Either can be done well; the owner should know which it will be, and what each person’s hourly rate is.

Court appearances are a separate question. If an objection is lodged, the Court may arrange a conciliation conference, presided over by a Commissioner, at which the parties must take part in good faith. If the parties agree on a decision the Court could have made, the Commissioner disposes of the proceedings on those terms. If not, the matter goes on to a hearing unless both parties consent to the Commissioner deciding it (Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW), s 34). The owner should ask who will appear at that conference, whether counsel will be briefed for the hearing and at what stage, and who instructs counsel. Where another law practice is retained, including a barrister, the owner’s lawyer must disclose that practice’s costs as well as its own (Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), s 175).

What happens once an objection is lodged in the Court?

The Court manages Class 3 compensation claims under its Practice Note, Class 3 Compensation Claims, which commenced on 12 November 2025. In outline:

  • Commencement. The objection is lodged with the Court by filing a Class 3 application (Form B) with accompanying documents (para 14), served within 7 days of filing (para 16). The first court date (the return date) is usually 12 weeks after filing. It is a directions hearing before a registrar, a court officer who settles the timetable (para 15).
  • Contentions. Contentions are each party’s written statement of the amount it says is payable and how that amount is made up. The issues in the claim are defined by them (para 17). Each must state, among other things, the amount contended for, its components under each relevant matter in section 55(a) to (f), the basis of the market value or special value, a schedule of losses attributable to disturbance under section 59(1)(a) to (e), and the other financial costs claimed under section 59(1)(f) (para 18). The owner’s contentions are due 4 weeks after filing, the authority’s 10 weeks after filing, and any reply 11 weeks after filing (paras 19–21).
  • Conciliation first. Before the first directions hearing the parties must discuss whether the claim is suitable for a conciliation conference and whether it is complex (para 23). The note records a presumption that every compensation claim is referred for at least one conciliation conference, and the parties must persuade the Court why it should not be (note to para 23(a)). A person able to decide whether the claim should settle must attend the conference in person or by an authorised nominee or, if that is not possible, be contactable with authority to confirm a settlement (para 70).
  • Documents. For a claim the Court finds not complex, the usual first directions (para 28) include a direction that the authority, within 7 days of the first directions hearing, give the owner access to and copies of the documents in its possession, custody or control relevant to the determination of compensation by the Valuer-General or the authority, at the owner’s reasonable copying cost (Schedule B, Part 1, direction 1). The Court may vary the usual directions.
  • Experts. A party may call expert evidence only as the Court directs under rule 31.19 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (para 45). Experts directed to confer must make their joint conference a genuine dialogue in a common effort to reach agreement, and the joint report is not to be a summary of pre-existing positions (para 57). Legal representatives do not attend the joint conference or take part in the joint report without the Court’s leave (para 58). At the hearing, experts in the same field give their evidence concurrently, in one session, unless the Court directs otherwise (para 40).
  • Attendances. Apart from separate applications on procedural questions, a claim should ordinarily come before the Court on no more than six occasions before the final hearing: the first directions hearing, a case management conference for complex matters, the conciliation conference, the second and third directions hearings, and a pre-hearing mention two weeks before the hearing (para 22). The second directions hearing is usually held 14 days after a conciliation conference that does not reach agreement (para 31).

Each of those steps adds legal, expert, counsel and filing costs, and a claim usually runs for many months. A conciliation conference may end in a settlement above, at or below the amount offered, or in no settlement; at a hearing the Court may determine a lower amount, and costs may be ordered against the owner (see costs below).

Two points follow for the choice of lawyer. The contentions are a statement of the whole claim, with the valuation basis and the disturbance schedule, due 4 weeks after filing, so work on the evidence should begin well before the objection is lodged. And the conciliation conference is the first occasion on which the claim can be settled before the Court, so the owner should know who will prepare for it, who will attend with authority to settle, and what each stage is likely to cost.

How does the lawyer work with valuers and other experts?

The lawyer’s part is to choose the experts the claim needs and to instruct them in writing on the assumptions the Act requires (for example, that the effect of the public purpose on value is left out of account). It is then to test the authority’s valuation line by line, and to prepare the experts for the joint conference and the hearing. Most of the evidence in a claim comes from experts: a valuer on market value and severance, an accountant or business valuer on disturbance to a business, a town planner on the land’s development potential, sometimes an engineer or an agronomist.

The Act allows compensation under six heads and no others (Just Terms Act, s 55):

  • the market value of the land on the date of its acquisition;
  • any special value of the land to the person on that date;
  • any loss attributable to severance;
  • any loss attributable to disturbance;
  • the disadvantage resulting from relocation;
  • any increase or decrease in the value of any other land of the person that adjoins or is severed from the acquired land, by reason of the public purpose.

Each head is a question of evidence, and the Court’s practice note requires each party’s contentions to set out the amount claimed under each relevant head. The owner should ask which experts the lawyer has instructed on acquisition claims, who will write the letter of instruction, and whether the lawyer will read the authority’s valuation report with the owner before any response is made. The articles on acquisition-date valuation, disturbance and disadvantage resulting from relocation explain what the evidence on those heads looks like.

Loss attributable to disturbance includes legal costs reasonably incurred by the person entitled to compensation in connection with the compulsory acquisition of the land (Just Terms Act, s 59(1)(a)). It also includes valuation fees of a qualified valuer reasonably incurred in connection with the acquisition, within section 59(1)(b), but not fees calculated by reference to the value of the land as assessed by the valuer. The owner should ask the lawyer to state this position precisely, and to say which of the lawyer’s own costs it covers. The article on costs in compulsory acquisition sets out how those costs differ from the costs of Court proceedings, and the records that support a claim.

Several things follow. The costs must be reasonably incurred and connected with the acquisition, which is a question of fact on which the authority or the Court may take a different view from the owner. The owner, not the authority, is the lawyer’s client and must pay the lawyer’s invoices under the costs agreement. Recovery in full is not assured. Court costs are separate: the Court decides them in its discretion, and a formal offer of settlement, or the way the case is run, can lead to an order that the owner bear its own costs or pay the authority’s. And an objection can produce less, not more: the Court may determine an amount lower than the offer. If the compensation it determines is no more than 10 per cent above the amount offered, the Court may also cancel or reduce the interest that has accrued since the proceedings began (Just Terms Act, s 66(4)). Counsel’s fees, expert fees and filing fees fall due as the case runs, whatever the outcome. The firm’s land acquisition page also answers who pays these costs.

What must a lawyer give a client before starting?

A law practice in New South Wales must, when a client first gives instructions or as soon as practicable afterwards, tell the client in writing how legal costs will be calculated and give an estimate of the total. The practice must also disclose any significant change to either as it arises (Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), s 174). No disclosure is required where the total legal costs, excluding GST and disbursements, are not likely to exceed a lower threshold set by the Uniform Rules, and below a higher threshold the practice may instead give the client the uniform standard disclosure form (Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), s 174(4), (5)). Most of the Part of the Uniform Law that holds these rules does not apply to a commercial or government client, a category that includes a public company and a large proprietary company (Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), s 170). For a client to whom the Part applies, the same Law provides that:

  • the disclosure must tell the client of the right to negotiate a costs agreement and the billing method, to receive a bill and request an itemised bill, and to seek the assistance of the designated local regulatory authority in a dispute about legal costs (Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), s 174);
  • a costs agreement must be written or evidenced in writing (Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), s 180);
  • a practice must charge costs that are no more than fair and reasonable in all the circumstances: the costs must be proportionately and reasonably incurred, and proportionate and reasonable in amount (Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), s 172);
  • if the practice does not make the disclosure, the costs agreement is void and the client need not pay until the costs have been assessed or a costs dispute determined, except as the Uniform Rules provide (Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), s 178).

For an acquisition claim, the owner should look in the disclosure for:

  • an estimate broken down by stage: negotiation, the claim, the objection and contentions, the conciliation conference, the hearing;
  • whether the work is charged by time or at a fixed fee for defined stages;
  • the hourly rate of each person who will work on the matter;
  • how disbursements such as valuers’ and counsel’s fees are treated;
  • what happens under the costs agreement if costs are not recovered, or are ordered against the owner.

What should an owner ask a compulsory acquisition lawyer at the first meeting?

  1. How much of the firm’s compulsory acquisition work is for owners, and how much for acquiring authorities?
  2. Is there any conflict with the acquiring authority in this matter, and when will the conflict check be done?
  3. Who will run the matter day to day, and who will review it?
  4. Who will appear at the conciliation conference and at a hearing, and when would counsel be briefed?
  5. Which valuers and other experts has the lawyer instructed on acquisition claims, and who will write the letter of instruction?
  6. Under which heads of compensation in section 55 does the lawyer expect this claim to be made, and what evidence will each need?
  7. What is the estimate of legal costs by stage, and on what basis is it charged?
  8. Which of those costs may be claimed as disturbance, within section 59, and which may not?
  9. What are the risks and costs of an objection to the Court compared with accepting the offer?
  10. What should the owner not sign, say or do until the lawyer has advised?

The answers need not all be favourable to the lawyer. A clear answer that the firm has not acted on a claim of this kind, or that a particular head is unlikely to succeed, is worth more than a confident one that turns out to be wrong.

What should an owner bring?

  • Every letter, notice and offer from the acquiring authority, with the envelope or email showing when it arrived.
  • The title documents, any lease or licence, and any mortgage.
  • Any valuation received, whether commissioned by the owner or supplied by the authority.
  • For a business, the last three years’ financial statements and tax returns, the lease, and any evidence of relocation options considered.
  • Plans, photographs and any council or planning documents about the land.
  • A note of any conversation with the authority’s representatives, with dates.

The service page also lists documents to collect.

What are the warning signs when choosing a lawyer?

Some statements call for a further question.

  • A promised outcome or a stated success rate. Compensation depends on the evidence under each head and on the Court’s assessment of it. No lawyer can promise an amount, and a success rate says little about another owner’s claim.
  • A statement that the authority will pay all the owner’s legal costs. The position is the one set out under costs above: legal costs reasonably incurred in connection with the acquisition may form part of disturbance, recovery in full is not assured, and Court costs are decided separately and may be ordered against the owner.
  • No written costs disclosure, or an estimate that does not name the stages. The disclosure is a legal obligation, and an estimate that cannot be broken down by stage is harder to check.
  • No one named as running the matter. The owner should know who is doing the work and who is reviewing it.
  • Advice to sign the authority’s documents first and claim later. An access agreement, an acquisition agreement or a release can settle more than it appears to. The owner should understand what it settles before signing it.
  • Pressure to delay an objection until a valuation is complete. The objection must be lodged within the period in section 66 whether or not a valuation is complete; a person who misses it is taken to have accepted the offer, and the Court will hear a late objection only if satisfied that there is good cause for the delay. The lawyer should explain how the valuation evidence will be obtained for the proceedings, and the costs risk, without letting the period pass.
  • A title or an experience claim the owner cannot check. The Law Society of New South Wales accredits practitioners in named areas of law, and its public Register of Solicitors includes details of accredited practitioners. A claimed accreditation, and whether its area is the one the claim needs, can be checked there or with the Law Society. Some experience can be checked against the published decisions of the Land and Environment Court, which name counsel and the law firms on the record; matters that settled, and work done in-house or at an earlier firm, do not appear under the lawyer’s own name.
  • No account of the Court’s procedure. A lawyer who runs Class 3 claims can say what the contentions must contain, when the conciliation conference falls, and who must attend it with authority to settle.

Where to read about the firm

Stone & Pillar Legal acts for affected owners, tenants, businesses and developers, not for acquiring authorities. Its About page records who acts and how the firm checks conflicts, and its experience page gives examples of matters Michael Themis advised or acted on during his career, including in earlier private-practice and government roles. The compulsory acquisition service page sets out the acquisition process, the heads of compensation and the costs risk of proceedings in the Court.

The firm’s land acquisition tool helps prepare an acquisition, access or project-impact enquiry for preliminary review. It does not assess entitlement, compensation, deadlines or an offer.

Frequently asked questions

Does an owner need a lawyer to respond to a proposed acquisition notice?

No law requires it. A proposed acquisition notice must generally be given at least 90 days before the land is compulsorily acquired, and it asks the owner to lodge a claim for compensation within the period it states. What the owner does and signs in that period affects what can be claimed later, so owners commonly engage a lawyer at or before that stage so that the claim, the valuation evidence and any agreement with the authority are prepared together.

What does a compulsory acquisition lawyer do that a valuer does not?

The valuer gives an opinion of value under each head of compensation and may give evidence of it. The lawyer frames the claim, instructs the valuer in writing on the assumptions the Act requires, tests the authority's valuation, negotiates, and runs any proceedings in the Land and Environment Court. Most claims need both, and the lawyer's letter of instruction to the valuer is one of the most important documents in the claim.

Does the acquiring authority pay the owner's legal costs?

Not directly. Legal costs reasonably incurred in connection with the compulsory acquisition can form part of the compensation as loss attributable to disturbance under section 59(1)(a) of the Just Terms Act, and valuation fees of a qualified valuer within section 59(1)(b), but not fees calculated by reference to the value of the land as assessed by the valuer. The owner remains responsible for the lawyer's invoices under the costs agreement, and recovery in full is not assured. The costs of proceedings in the Land and Environment Court are a separate matter for the Court's discretion: an owner who objects may recover less than was spent, and an owner who does not better a formal offer of settlement may be ordered to pay the authority's costs from the time of the offer. Whether to object is a decision on which to take advice.

Can an owner engage a lawyer who has acted for an acquiring authority?

Yes, provided there is no conflict in the particular matter. Experience on an authority's side gives familiarity with the statutory process as authorities apply it. It does not permit the use of that authority's confidential information, and a lawyer who holds such information that is material to the matter may be unable to act. The lawyer should disclose any current or past relationship with the authority concerned, and the firm's conflict check should be done before the retainer begins.

Can an owner change lawyers during a compulsory acquisition?

Yes. When a retainer ends, the former practice must give the client, or a person the client authorises, the client's documents as soon as reasonably possible when asked, unless it has an effective lien (Australian Solicitors' Conduct Rules, rule 14.1). Where it claims a lien for unpaid costs over documents essential to current proceedings, rule 15 provides for them to go to the new solicitor on terms that protect those costs. The costs agreement sets out what is payable for work already done. A change close to a conciliation conference or a hearing needs time for the new lawyer to read in.

What happens in the Land and Environment Court if the owner objects to the compensation offered?

The objection is a Class 3 compensation claim. Under the Court's practice note for Class 3 compensation claims, in force from 12 November 2025, the objection is lodged by filing a Class 3 application. Each party then files contentions stating the amount it says is payable and how it is made up, and the Court will ordinarily refer the claim to a conciliation conference presided over by a Commissioner. There is a presumption that every compensation claim goes to at least one conciliation conference. If the conference does not settle the claim, the Court gives directions for expert evidence and joint expert reports and fixes a hearing date once the evidence is filed. Each step adds cost and time, the Court may determine an amount lower than the offer, and costs may be ordered against the owner. Whether to object is a decision on which to take advice.

This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.

Michael Themis

Author

Michael Themis

Principal Solicitor · Stone & Pillar Legal

Michael brings experience of both private practice and government to planning, environmental regulation and compulsory acquisition. Trained at Herbert Smith Freehills and King & Wood Mallesons, he has senior in-house experience across the Commonwealth and New South Wales governments.

(02) 8014 5817 michael@stonepillar.com.au Level 13, 111 Elizabeth Street
Sydney NSW 2000

Legislation on this page

Your matter

Deciding who should act in your acquisition?

Tell us the stage reached and what you have received from the authority. On a short preliminary call we can say whether we can assist and what the first step would be.

How we help with a compensation claim

Speak with a lawyer

30 minutes · Phone or Teams · No charge

The complimentary 30-minute preliminary call is intended to discuss whether we can assist and what an initial scope of work would involve. It is not intended to provide legal advice. Ask us to confirm in writing the work we have agreed to undertake.

Speak with a lawyer Call