My compensation valuation needs testing
A valuation is useful when its evidence and assumptions answer the statutory question. We review the interest being valued, the development or operating assumptions and the points of disagreement before further expert work is commissioned.
- New South Wales
- Issue overview
On this page
If you have received a decision or notice, a strict review or appeal period may already be running. Confirm it promptly and do not rely on an online enquiry.
This page may be relevant if:
- An acquisition offer relies on a valuation you question
- Development potential or comparable sales are disputed
- Different experts are using inconsistent assumptions
What this usually means
- Section 56 of the Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 assesses market value at the acquisition date on the statutory willing-buyer and willing-seller basis, disregarding specified effects including those of the acquisition project.
- The report needs to value the relevant property interest. The value of the land, a leasehold interest and the business's claimed costs should not be treated as interchangeable.
- A valuation based on a different potential use needs to be checked against special-value and disturbance claims. Section 61 excludes financial advantages necessarily forgone and financial losses necessarily incurred in realising that potential.
What commonly matters
-
Comparable evidence
Test the location, date, property characteristics and adjustments behind comparable transactions. A headline price alone may conceal important differences.
-
Planning and feasibility
Support development assumptions with controls, approvals and physical constraints. Allow for timing, infrastructure and costs where relevant to the method.
-
A proportionate expert brief
Identify the decisive disagreement and the evidence needed to resolve it. Consider the likely value of further reports alongside their cost and litigation risk.
How we help
- Settle valuation instructions around the statutory issues
- Coordinate planning, engineering and valuation evidence
- Test competing reports for negotiation or proceedings
Related reading
- Compulsory acquisition Choosing a lawyer for a compulsory acquisition claim in NSW How a NSW landowner chooses a compulsory acquisition lawyer: the work at each stage, who the lawyer acts for, who runs the claim, costs and the Court.
- Compulsory acquisition Disadvantage resulting from relocation in NSW acquisitions When disadvantage resulting from relocation (formerly solatium) is payable in a NSW acquisition, how the indexed cap works and the evidence for a claim.
- Compulsory acquisition Disturbance loss in NSW compulsory acquisition How NSW compulsory acquisition law treats relocation, duty, mortgage and other disturbance costs, and the evidence needed to support a claim.
This page is general information only and is not legal advice. It may not be current, and how the law applies depends on the specific facts. For advice on your situation, contact Stone & Pillar Legal.
Related situations
- Compulsory acquisition My land is being acquired Advice on proposed acquisition notices, compensation claims, valuation issues and disturbance losses.
- Compulsory acquisition Only part of my land is being acquired NSW partial acquisitions and easements: the interest taken, retained land, access, severance, project effects and evidence for a compensation claim.
- Compulsory acquisition An acquisition means moving my business NSW acquisition and business relocation: claimant interests, replacement premises, continuity, evidence and the statutory basis for claimed relocation costs.
- Compulsory acquisition I dispute the compensation offered for my land NSW compulsory acquisition compensation objections and Class 3 proceedings: notices, evidence, negotiation, lower-award risk and discretionary costs.
Where to start
Discuss acquisition valuation evidence
Tell us what the valuation assumes and which issue needs testing. We can discuss the legal and expert work that an initial review would require.
30 minutes · Phone or Teams · No charge
The complimentary 30-minute preliminary call is intended to discuss whether we can assist and what an initial scope of work would involve. It is not intended to provide legal advice. Ask us to confirm in writing the work we have agreed to undertake.